Skip to content
KudoStart for free

How to price a membership tier without guessing

Three tiers, one obvious middle, and a price that ends in 9 or 5. What 1,900 pages taught us about the first month of memberships.

Sofia Marchetti · 7 min read

The question I get most in onboarding calls is not how to set up memberships. It is what to charge. People arrive with a spreadsheet of what other creators charge, a feeling that their work is worth less than that, and a plan to start low and raise it later. Raising prices later is harder than it sounds, so let’s start in the right place.

We looked at the first 90 days of 1,900 pages that launched memberships this year. Here is what the ones that kept growing had in common.

Three tiers, and the middle one is the point

Pages with one tier convert well in the first week and then flatten. Pages with five tiers confuse people. Three tiers, with the middle one marked as the one most people choose, did best on every measure we checked: more members, higher average price, fewer cancellations in month two.

The cheapest tier exists so that nobody feels priced out. The top tier exists so that the middle looks reasonable, and so that your most devoted fans have somewhere to go. The middle is where you want most people to land, so give it the perk that matters most to you: early access, the monthly process video, the recipes.

Lina Ortiz’s three tiers in November 2026: 1,284 members.
TierLina’s priceMembersShare of revenue
Fan$450221%
Studio$967162%
Patron$2511117%

Price for the work, not for the fear

Most first-time creators price their middle tier at $3 to $5. The median middle tier on pages that were still growing after 90 days was $9. The members on those pages did not cancel more often; they cancelled slightly less, because a $9 tier promises something specific and delivers it every month.

A useful test: write down what a member gets in a month. If it takes you more than four hours to make, $3 is not a price, it is an apology.

Numbers that end in 9 or 5

We tested this one twice because we didn’t believe it. Tiers at $9 got 11% more sign-ups than tiers at $10 with the same perks. Tiers at $25 did better than $24. Round numbers above $20 feel deliberate; just-under numbers below $10 feel like a good deal. Fans pay in their own currency, and Kudo rounds converted prices to the same kind of ending.

Raise prices for new members only

When you change a tier’s price, Kudo asks whether existing members keep the old one. Say yes. Members who joined early took a chance on you, and keeping their price is the cheapest loyalty programme there is. On pages that raised prices for new members only, existing members cancelled at the same rate as before. On pages that raised everyone, cancellations doubled for two months.

What to do this week

  1. Write down what a member gets each month, per tier, in one line each.
  2. Set the middle tier first, between $7 and $12, then build the other two around it.
  3. Mark the middle as Most chosen. It will be, within a month.
  4. Turn on pausing, so members who are short one month don’t have to leave.

And if you would like a second opinion, book a call with our creator success team from your dashboard. We look at a few hundred pages a month and we are happy to look at yours.

Written by

Sofia Marchetti

Creator success, Milan. Supports Lina Ortiz on Kudo (owns three moon vases).

Keep reading.

Ideas are cheap. A page takes an afternoon.

Claim your handle, switch on one app, and see what your fans do with it.